So, after much research, and fabric testing... I made my toga out of a sheet set. I am the Mcgyver of cosplay!
I had a few ideas that I liked, but ended up going with the sort of poofy bag look that I thought was fairly authentic.
There was some lace detail on the top of the sheet that I left in place, you can kinda see it in this picture.
Makeup was kept fairly simple. Peaches n' Cream finishing powder, Corset blush, and Roses n' Violets lipstick.
Eyeshadow is Aromaleigh White Wedding on the inner corner, Zeus under the eye, and Wonder over the lid. I am so glad I bought Wonder from Peace, Love, and Sparkles. It's such a great all over color for me.